Egregoros

Signal feed

Timeline

Post

Remote status

Context

3
To my American comrades,

Things are bad right now, but you can take some comfort in studying good Marxist theory to understand how and why the nation is in this state. Your local library likely has Marxist literature. Reading it is an act of defiance against fascism. Knowledge is power.

Mao and Lenin can also give insight into how late stage capitalism comes to a close.
@Nimbius666

> Your local library

Or must marxists.org has everything. Basically all of it.

> studying good Marxist theory to understand how and why the nation is in this state.

> Reading it is an act of defiance against fascism.

I don't think that anything I read stopped fascism. It's essentially a manual of failure written by the people that either lost to fascists or, once they got power, were indistinguishable from fascists.

The Federalist papers are a better read.
hungry_santa.jpg
@p @Nimbius666 Marx has glaring shortcomings in his thought (especially wrt LTV and certain economic presumptions) & his most notable adherents failed as well -- but I think part of the problem is that we take more modern (i.e. mid to late 20th century) Marxists at their word that his work is a singular, monolithic, coherent system of thought with clear correct interpretations.

Taken piece-meal, I think there's a lot of value though, especially in regard to concepts of commodification, reification, and estrangement/alienation -- basically I think the guy had more value on a traditional philosophical and even psychological register rather than economic or sociological.
@smithy @Nimbius666 You're replying to a year-old post.

> Taken piece-meal, I think there's a lot of value

Essentially, everything he said was in one of two categories: wrong or obvious.

But I wasn't talking about Marx directly, and I think most of the stuff I read on there was Trotsky. That site has essentially everything from all of the Marxists; it aims to be complete, as far as I can tell, so there's no editorializing or bowdlerization or censorship or omissions or anything. If you want to read what they wrote, that's a great place to get it.

Replies

5
@p @Nimbius666 My Bad! I am reaccustoming myself to pleroma and think I saw a more recent response in that thread or maybe it was reposted! Didn't even notice it was that old

And wrt marxists dot org -- yes, it's a very useful site. My point was that their idea that "Marxism" is a coherent whole, or at least something that has to be taken wholesale rather than piecemeal isn't true. My only disagreement would be that there is some not-wrong and non-trivial writing.